Insights Sources included

Your chatbot is not a separate legal entity.

In 2024 an airline argued that its chatbot was responsible for its own words. It lost. South African lawyers think a local court would land in the same place. Here’s what that means if a bot talks to your customers.

By Mathieu Sroussi, founder of Syrup 3 min read

On 11 November 2022, Jake Moffatt’s grandmother died. The same day, he asked Air Canada’s website chatbot about bereavement fares.

The chatbot told him he could book at the normal fare and claim the bereavement discount afterwards, within 90 days. He did. Air Canada refused the refund. Its bereavement page, a click away from the chatbot, said the policy didn’t apply once you’d travelled.

Moffatt took it to British Columbia’s Civil Resolution Tribunal. Air Canada’s defence was, in effect, that it couldn’t be held liable for what its chatbot said. The tribunal read that as an argument that the chatbot was a separate legal entity, responsible for its own actions. Its response: “This is a remarkable submission.”

The ruling, in February 2024, was short. The chatbot is part of Air Canada’s website. Air Canada is responsible for all the information on its website. And a customer has no reason to check one part of the site against another. Air Canada paid CAD 650.88 in damages, plus interest and fees.1

A small amount. A large precedent.

Would it land the same way here?

Probably. In September 2026, three Webber Wentzel lawyers looked at the case from a South African angle. Their view: our law of delict already recognises negligent misrepresentation as a basis for liability, and the Consumer Protection Act already prohibits misleading representations to consumers.23 A company that deploys a bot is likely to carry what the bot says.

They add that no reported South African case has tested this on a chatbot yet. So the first one will be somebody’s customer, with a screenshot. (Make sure it isn’t yours.)

Why bots say wrong things

Not because they’re malicious. Usually for one of three reasons.

Two sources disagree. The bot reads from an old page, an old PDF or a policy that has since changed. Air Canada’s chatbot and its bereavement page said opposite things, and both were “the website”.

It answers when it should pass. Most chatbots are built to answer. A question outside what they know gets a confident guess instead of “let me get someone”.

Nobody reads the transcripts. The bot went live, the project closed, and checking what it said last week is nobody’s job.

None of those is an AI problem. They’re ownership problems.

What to put in place now

You don’t need a new policy framework. You need four things, and a name next to each.

One source of truth. The bot answers from the same documents your team uses. When a policy changes, the bot’s source changes the same day. If two versions of a rule exist, the bot will find the wrong one.

A lane, and a door. Write down what the bot may answer and what it must hand to a person: complaints, refunds, anything legal, anything about money, anything it isn’t sure of. A good bot says “let me get someone” often. That’s a feature.

A person who reads it. Someone in your business reads a sample of what the bot said every week. Twenty conversations, fifteen minutes, pass or fail. If you can’t name that person, the software is running your customer service.

An off switch. The same person can switch the bot off today, without logging a ticket.

The real question

The question isn’t whether AI is safe to put in front of customers. It’s whether you’d let a new staff member answer customers with no training, no supervisor and nobody reading their emails. Nobody would. A bot deserves the same treatment, for the same reason: what it says, you said.

So, who owns yours?

Sources

  1. Moffatt v. Air Canada, 2024 BCCRT 149, Civil Resolution Tribunal of British Columbia, 14 February 2024. decisions.civilresolutionbc.ca ↑
  2. Erwyn Durman, Manno Manavhela and Precious Maphupha (Webber Wentzel), “AI chatbots and corporate liability: a South African perspective”, 16 September 2026. techfinancials.co.za ↑
  3. Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008, section 41, false, misleading or deceptive representations. acts.co.za ↑

Got a workflow in mind? Let’s look at it.

Thirty minutes, free, no deck.

Book a call